Metal Roof V Clay Tile: Which Roofing Material Is Best For Me
If you are in the market for a new roof, you already know its a big, expensive decision with a lot of factors to consider. When it comes to picking between a metal roof or clay tile roof, your decision becomes especially difficult since both are quality materials that have a lot to offer.
At Western States Metal Roofing, we hope to help make that decision easier by doing a head to head comparison of these two popular roofing choices. While we only manufacture and sell metal roofing, we realize its not always the best choice for everyone. We want to give you an overview of both types of roofing materials so you can decide which type of roof is right for you.
In this article, expect to see metal roofing and clay tile roofing compared in terms of:
Diy Vs Hiring A Professional
Some homeowners may consider installing the tiles by themselves. While this may save you a lot in installation costs, it can be risky if you dont get it right. Faulty installation can cause leakages or damages that may be costly to repair. Also, you risk damaging the tiles in the process.
We always recommend hiring a professional installer to handle the installation for you. However, you should ensure the contractor has installed roof tiles before. Ask for testimonials from happy customers or proof of previous projects.
Asphalt Shingles Are Cheaper Up Front But Metal Is A Better Long Term Value
Remember the cliché we started with? You get what you pay for. Heres where that comes in
Life Expectancy
Say you get the high end of asphalt roofing, the pricey product with 50-year life expectancy youre looking at around $6,000 for that same 2,300-square-foot roof material. But asphalt, unlike metal, degrades as it ages. The marketers may say itll last 50 years, but its efficacy against fire and wind, even rainstorms, will decline dramatically with each decade. Asphalt is a 20- to 30-year roof in most BEST cases, whatever the marketing materials may say and the homes resale value in year 25 will reflect that, even on 50-year asphalt shingles. If you go to sell your home that has a 20-year old asphalt shingle roof, its a good bet that the buyer will ask for that to be replaced or at least a discount on the asking price of your home.
Metal, though, has been proven to last decades and newer innovations have made metal roofs tougher than ever. A 50-year metal roof will indeed last 50 years if well-cared for . 60 years is a long time to not have to worry about roof replacement.
Metal Roofing Aesthetics
If you want that traditional asphalt shingle or architectural shingle look, there are metal shingle options available that are great options. Many of these options can be HOA approved as well. Metal shingles offer the same cost and quality options as do metal panels.
Metal: More Than Just a Roof
You May Like: Are Roof Solar Panels Worth It
Tile Roofs Look Better
This is not always true, but for the most part, a tiled roof looks better than a metal roof. Over the years, people are going to come up with new ways to make metal roofs look great. However, at this point, metal roofs are still pretty ugly when compared to tiled roofs. If you are looking for a fancier metal roof, then it will probably cost you a lot more than a regular metal roof.
Rubber Roof Tiles Cost Guide 2022
Roof tiles have come a long way over the years. Clay, slate, and concrete have been the materials of choice for many years. However, technology has paved the way for cheaper and lighter alternatives like rubber.
But how expensive is a rubber roof? Is it cost-effective in the long run? In this guide, we tell you how much you will pay for a fully installed tile roof. We also compare it to other options in the market to help you make an informed choice.
Recommended Reading: How Much To Replace Roof And Gutters
Is It Ok To Put A Metal Roof Over Shingles
In almost every case, the answer is yes, you can lay down a new metal roof over an existing shingle roof. This is one of the many reasons metal roofs keep growing in popularity their installation doesnt require completely tearing off the existing roof, which is a time-consuming and expensive job.
Types Of Roof Tiles 2022
Have you settled on a tile roof? We know the dilemma can be overwhelming with so many varying styles and designs on the market. That is why we compiled this comprehensive list on your behalf. By the end of the article, you should be familiar with the different tiles available to make an informed choice.
Read Also: How Much Do Louvered Roofs Cost
What To Learn More
- If youd like to see a variety of different options all in one place, check out our Residential Photo Library here. Simply open the product filter button and select Met-Tile to see a few of our favorite completed projects.
- Visit our website to learn more about our metal tile panel called Met-Tile.
- Simply contact us. Were always here to help!
Learn everything you need to know about Residential Metal Roofing. Check out our metal roofing resources for inspiration and answers to your questions.
Tiles Are Heavy & Quiet
Roof tiles are generally hefty and will provide exceptional soundproofing. Unlike metal roofs, tile roofing has excellent sound insulation and acoustic performance. The thermal mass of roof tiles also helps to regulate temperatures indoors, providing thermal insulation. In saying that, your roof structure must be able to handle the weight of a tile roof as the materials are considerably heavier than other roofing materials.
Also Check: Can You Put A Metal Roof Over A Shingle Roof
How Much Does Metal Roofing Cost
In general, the upfront cost of a metal roof is much higher than the cost of a roof containing asphalt shingles. However, given a metal roofs durability, the overall cost of installing and maintaining it is much lower than needing a total roof replacement every 15 to 20 years.
Here are some of the most common metal roofing materials and how much they cost to purchase and install. The overall prices are calculated for the average American roof size of 1,700 square feet.
Steel Shingles And Tiles
There are several common types of steel roofing. Galvanized steel, which is coated with zinc to deter corrosion, is a popular choice for its strength and durability. A cheaper alternative is Galvalume, which is aluminum-coated steel. On the high end of the scale is stainless steel, which is a rare but striking choicethe Chrysler Building, for example, is roofed with stainless steel.
A 100-square-foot Galvalume panel costs between $75 and $250 and installs for a total of about $5.50 per square foot. Galvanized steel, which is a bit more expensive, runs about $3.35 to $4.25 per square foot, and materials plus installation come out to about $10 per square foot, or $17,000 to $25,000 total. Stainless steel is quite a bit more expensive at $10 to $16 per square foot for materials and as much as $15.50 more per square foot for installation.
Don’t Miss: How Do I Calculate Roofing Squares
Colorbond Roof Vs Tiles Heat
In terms of energy efficiency, both tile and Colorbond roofing materials provide adequate thermal insulation for homes. Asphalt, concrete, and clay tiles may absorb heat, whereas Colorbond will use solar reflection technology to reflect the heat away from the house. Roof tiles rely on solid and heavy thermal mass to provide a home with energy efficiency, Colorbond roofs rely on tried and tested technology to make a property more thermally efficient.
Is A Rubber Roof Cheaper Than Shingles
Installing rubber roof tiles is undoubtedly cheaper than other tile options. However, it is still more than the cost of installing shingles.
A rubber tile roof will cost two or three times the price of asphalt shingles. While it will cost you $300 to $500 per square to have one installed, an asphalt roof costs $100 per square or less.
Read Also: How To Repair A Leaking Flat Roof
What Are The Best Roofs For Hurricanes In Florida
Out of the six common roofing types in Florida, the most effective roofing for hurricanes are metal, concrete, and clay tile roofs. Metal roofs can endure strong winds up to 160 mph, followed by concrete and clay tile roofs. Both these tile roofs are heavy enough to remain intact in the presence of powerful winds.
When it comes to flying/falling debris, all roofs struggle in different ways. Metal roofs can dent, tiles can break, and shingles can crack. The upside to tile roofs, however, is that broken tiles are easily replaced, so long as the replacement tiles can be found.
What Is The Cheapest Type Of Roof
Asphalt is the cheapest of all roofing materials in the market. This makes it a perfect option for homeowners facing budgetary constraints. A shingle measuring one square foot retails for as low as $1. Homeowners with varying preferences can also choose from a wide range of organic and inorganic asphalt roofing styles.
Don’t Miss: How Long Do Pvc Roofs Last
Spanish Clay Tiles Characteristics Advantages & Disadvantages
The practice of using clay tile as a roofing material has been around for centuries, with some uses dating back to China as early as 10,000 B.C. Using clay roof tiles eventually spread throughout Asia and Europe, where new styles and advanced options became available . This building material finally made its way to America during colonization in the 17th century and is still used as a roofing material.
Wood Shakes And Shingles: 30 To 50 Years
Wood roofs have declined in popularity in Arizona over time and the quality of materials has seen a general decrease as well. Still, many homeowners like the aesthetic of a wood shingle roof and prefer it to other roofing options.
- Advantages of Wood Shakes and Shingles: Because wood shake roofs are such a layered system, they have a proven lifespan that can outlive other kinds of roofs if properly maintained.
- Disadvantages of Wood Shakes and Shingles: The main disadvantage of wood roofs is that they are not fire resistant without the addition of special chemicals. Because of this, some municipalities in Arizona have put restrictions on how much a roof can be made of wood shake shingles. Shake roofs can also be attractive to termites if not properly treated. Shake roofs are also expensive compared to other roofing systems.
- Eco-Friendly: Shake roofs are very environmentally friendly as they can be reused after use for various things, such as mulch, or can be converted into pellets for wood burning stoves.
Recommended Reading: How To Lay Out Shingles On A Roof
Which Roof Type Is Right For You
When it comes time to replace your roof, understandably, you want to select an option that not only looks great, but one that is going to last. Since metal roofing and tile roofing do come with their own unique set of advantages, the truth is, either is a solid option for a home.
But if youre unsure what is best for you, we can help. We offer free estimates and can help in making a selection for your new roofing project. Contact us today to get started.
Metal Roofing Cost Guide
Compare Quotes from This Old House Approved Solar Installers
Jump To: Benefits of Metal Roofing | Metal Roofing Costs | Is a Metal Roof Worth It? | FAQs
The choice to put a metal roof on your house is a significant financial investment, particularly in comparison to materials like asphalt composite shingles. However, there are a number of valid reasons for making this switch, including the increased durability and value of metal roofing. Youll need to budget carefully, but many homeowners find that metal roofing provides a great return on investment and lasts two to three times longer than a traditional roof.
In this guide, well break down the benefits of a metal roof and the costs of different types of metal roofing materials to help you decide whether a metal roof is right for your house.
Recommended Reading: How To Sell Roofing Jobs
How To Make Metal Roofing
We, a Vietnam roll forming machine manufacturer, customized design and manufacture a wide range of good solutions and products for companies operating in the sheet metal, construction and manufacturing industries. If you are wonder which metal roof tile making machine is suitable for your business, please contact us for more consultation.
Take a look at how roll forming machines work below:
Labor Cost To Install Metal Roof
Labor costs to install a metal roof ranges from $3.50 to $12 per square foot, with most homeowners paying about $5 per square foot to install metal roofing. Labor comes out to between $3,000 to install an ordinary roof, and closer to $8,000 for more substantial, thicker, high-end materials. The cost of labor is around 3 to 5 times the rate of the materials alone.
Read Also: Can I Pressure Wash My Roof
Maintenance Of Colorbond Roofing
Offering a sturdy and smooth surface, Colorbond roofs are relatively low maintenance. Regular cleaning and washing your Colorbond roof will keep it performing better for longer. Even when maintenance work is required, there is little chance of damage to the steel sheets as Colorbond is remarkably resilient.
Cost Of Metal Roofs Vs Shingles
Metal roofing costs between $5.50 to $14 per square foot installed vs. an asphalt shingle roof which costs between $3.50 and $7 per square foot installed. Compared to an asphalt roof on a 1,200 square foot single-story home costing $4,200 to 8,500, metal roofs cost $8,400 to $19,000+.
Many homeowners would instead install metal roofs that look like shingles for a more residential look. Other than metal roof cost lying at 2 to 3 times to cost of asphalt shingles, metal roofs are an infinitely better investment because of their long life and low maintenance. Most metal shingles are made of galvanized steel or aluminum, but some companies offer copper and zinc shingles too.
Don’t Miss: How Much For A Patio Roof
Metal Roofs Dont Insulate As Well As Tiles
A metal roof will heat up quite a bit and will conduct that heat down through your house. On the other hand, it will not help you very much if heat is escaping from your home. Obviously, you can insulate your attic yourself with foams and layers of different materials. Nevertheless, on their own, tile roofs insulate better, and they do not pass as much heat down into your house.
Metal Roof Underlayment Costs
At an average cost of $0.06 to $0.21 per square foot, underlayment acts as a secondary barrier to water and wind damage for metal roofing. Different roofing professionals will likely have different underlayment options available for your roofing project. Underlay is attached with staples, roofing caps, or the back side of the product has an adhesive layer to stick it to the roof deck.
There are two types of underlayment product available synthetic and felt paper, also known as asphalt felt, tar paper, or roofing tar paper. The heavier the felt, the better.
Read Also: How Much Does It Cost To Resheet A Roof
Galvalume Metal Roofing Prices
Galvalume metal costs $0.75 to $2.50 per square foot and starts at $5.50 per square foot installed. Galvalume is a combination of steel, aluminum, zinc, and silicone. A wide range of color options is available.
Galvalume metal roof panels typically last around 60 years however, they have a propensity to completely degrade when in contact with other metals like copper or iron, or other building materials like concrete, brick, or the treated wood found in decks. Also, unless treated with KJynar coatings, galvalumes finish can fade in color or develop a buildup of a chalk-like residue, as well as oil canning, which changes the look of the metal.
Do Metal Roofs Affect Wifi
Metal roofs are an attractive and long-lasting option for homes, but many homeowners worry these roofs can interfere with Wi-Fi and even cell phone signals, affecting how they use technology in the home. While a metal roof can interfere with a wireless connection, it is unlikely to be the only culprit.
Read Also: How Much Is It For A New Roof
Metal Roof Vs Shingles In Cold Climates
If you experience cold temperatures in your local area, comfort and energy savings are essential, especially in the winter. Asphalt shingles tend to absorb heat from the sunlight and transfer it inside your home. As a result, your heating system may not have to work as hard to provide a comfortable indoor temperature, and you can save money on your utility bills.
However, in most cases, a metal roof can warm up your indoor living space more effectively than asphalt shingles. Since metal is a natural conductor, it can easily absorb sunlight and convert it into heat that makes your home comfortable in the winter. The sheathing that goes under this roofing material has insulating properties that keep the absorbed heat contained. Besides absorbing heat, metal roofs can also withstand snow and ice without suffering from moisture damage.
