Metal Roof Cost Vs Asphalt Shingles
For many homeowners looking to replace an old roof, the choice often boils down to metal vs. asphalt shingles. In the short run, traditional shingles are a very budget-friendly option, with prices starting as low as $3 per square foot installed. These are 3-tab shingles, that look flat and last only about 10-12 years, sometimes even less.
More expensive, designer architectural shingles, last up to 15 years, and look significantly better. They run $5-7 per square foot on average, but can cost as much as $7-8 per square foot installed. Thus you would be looking at spending anywhere from $4,500 to 10,500 for a new asphalt shingles roof on a 1,500 sq.ft. ranch style home.
To compare, the average cost for a metal roof is about 40-50% more than basic shingles. However, this roof will last at least twice as long, and will require minimal maintenance. Upon closer examination, the math is actually in favor of installing a metal roof. This is because you can get a low-end metal shingle, which is still superior in longevity and performance to the most expensive asphalt product, for about $6.5-7 per square foot installed.
Thus, you can install a new metal roof for about $9,750-10,500 on the same 1,500 sq.ft. ranch style home. This roof will protect your home in any weather, especially against ice dams, snow, rain, hail and fire. Many homeowners spend this much on an architectural asphalt roof, but dont get any of the benefits of metal.
Why Use A Metal Roof
There is a reason why metal roofing has been increasing its market share over recent years. Here are some of the greatest benefits of using a metal roof:
- Metal roofing is safe it does not attract lightning and is less combustible than conventional roofing
- Metal roofing is environmentally friendly
- It is sometimes possible to install metal roofing on top of other roof types
- Metal roofs offer high durability and can last a long time
- Metal roofing is not any noisier than any other roofing material
- Metal roofing can save you money on your energy bills
Read Also: Can You Put Skylights In A Metal Roof
Another Sample For An Over All Costs
$7 per Sq Ft for a 3 tab shingle roof with underlayment and labor = $2100.00
Skylight $300 for materials + time to cut the hole in the ceiling.
Materials Ventilation $700-1500
Total Cost: = ~$3000+taxes and fees
Additional costs for 1000 Sq Ft roof replacement: Removal of materials $300-600
Labor used to remove shingles and clean up $100-300
Inspections and permits $75 for inspection +$25 for permit. So from the looks of it, not a bad option if you have a small price range.
Don’t Miss: Average Shingle Roof Cost
How Much Does A Screw Down Panel Metal Roof Cost
A screw down panel metal roof starts around $4.50 per square foot.
Remember, I would not recommend putting a screw down metal roof over a heated space such as your home or office due to its lack of expansion capability. This doesn’t mean you cant put this type of metal roof over your home.
But to get the most out of your metal roof investment, I would recommend going with a standing seam metal roof system.
Is A Metal Roof Worth It
Installing a metal roof has a greater upfront cost than asphalt composite shingles, but it lasts much longer and provides substantial energy cost savings. Metal roof costs are comparable to roofs made of wooden shakes or slate tiles, but metal is sturdier and more durable. Compare your current budget against the budget needed to maintain other roofing materials before making your choice.
Also Check: Adding Gable Overhang To Existing Roof
Resale Value Of A Metal Roof
One of the greatest long term advantages of a metal roof is that it boasts a very high return on investment. Across the US, you can get at least 90% ROI when you resell a house with a metal roof. However, in areas with snow and ice dams, as well as fires and high winds, the ROI of a metal roof can be as high as 95-97%
Compared to asphalt shingles, a metal roof can boost your home value by as much as 5-6%. Most homeowners dont like to deal with roofing problems, and are more willing to buy home where their roof will last for decades to come without any leaks.
How To Choose A Color For Your Metal Roof
Much of the metal roofing color decision depends on your propertys style, the neighborhoods overall look, your climate, and your personal preferences.
For instance, if you prefer a more subtle look then you might want to pick a color that echoes your roofs siding, or is almost the same color for a chic monochrome appearance.
However, going for contrast can make for some great drama and lend your home some serious curbside appeal due to the visual impact of your new metal roof.
The color of your metal roof also plays a role as to how long it looks like new saturated colors or brighter shades tend to fade more quickly, while more neutral colors tend to weather in a way that looks more natural and that you might find more visually pleasing.
Our guide on roof shingle colors complete with visuals also applies to metal roofing with some caveats.
And naturally, when you are choosing the roofing colors for your home, always check in with your homeowners association or any similar governing bodies if applicable.
If you have a historic home and therefore are subject to specific colors or material types, or requirements for color palettes that may be otherwise limited, it is certainly better to know in advance if theyll have a problem with your new roof.
For instance, some color options for metal roofing include the often-dramatic look of bare metal.
Recommended Reading: How Much Does Shingle Roof Cost
Metal Roof Cost Calculator
Enter your address below and the metal roof cost calculator will obtain measurements for your roof using LiDAR measurements. It will also estimate roof replacement costs using data from the Craftsman Construction Cost Guide, which is the default cost estimating data used by almost everybody in the construction and insurance industries.
Area of your home
Do you need new gutters?
Tear off, removal and dumping of old roof?
Number of stories
What Is The Material Cost For A Metal Roof
The cost of metal roofing materials varies widely depending on which type of metal and finish you want. At the cheapest end of the scale, corrugated metal roofing sheets cost between $180 and $250 per square, according to Modernize. Premium copper sheets could set you back between $1,400 and $2,200 per square.
A mid-range roof material such as aluminum costs between roughly $325 and $575 per square. For an average-sized roof measuring 1,500 square feet, this adds up to a total average material cost of between $4,875 and $8,625.
Also Check: How Do I Know If My Roof Is Leaking
Snow And Ice Shedding
Metal roofs shed snow, ice, and rain easily. The dark surface absorbs sun rays and melts the snow, allowing it to slough off. This can help fight ice dams and recurrent water leaks from standing snow and ice melt on your roof. This will also prevent sagging in the future, which can happen with asphalt shingles that are 20+ years old.
Standing Seam Metal Roofing:
G90 Steel Standing Seam Expect to Pay: $19 $25.00 CAD per square foot installedAluminum Standing Seam Expect to Pay: $24 $30.00 CAD per square foot installedAluminum Standing Seam with Concealed Fasteners: $30.00+ per square foot installed and up depending on difficulty
Exotic Metal Roofing: example of a shingle style copper roof on a church.
Also Check: Cost Of New Roof California
Pitched Roofs Vs Flat Roofs
Flat roofs are on average less expensive than pitched ones. The latter is more difficult to clean. Its also harder to spot damage, especially towards the top, for pitched roofs. These realities often sway homeowners towards flat roofs. However, if youre already heading in that direction, keep in mind that while the initial installation may be cheaper, a flat roof will often require more maintenance and could end up costing you more in the long run, mainly because of drainage issues. Flat roofs dont drain as well, which can lead to quicker clogging and leaking, meaning that youll have to spend more time and money inspecting and taking care of it.
Defining Metal Roof Costs
To discuss costs, we need to start by defining two terms: first cost and life cycle cost. As you might expect, the first cost is the product cost on the day of purchase. Conversely, life cycle costs also include factors like the life expectancy and maintenance of a product over its lifetime.
For a better understanding, lets look at the comparison of a home office printer. The first costs for printer option #1 are $59.00, while the first costs for printer option #2 are $99.
Based on first costs alone, option #1 seems the logical choice however, upon reading reviews, it seems the print head on the cheaper-priced printer commonly fails within the first year and, of course, after the 90 day warranty expires. With an estimated repair bill of $50, the life cycle costs for printer #1 escalates to $109.
And suddenly, the higher-priced printer option #2 may offer better life cycle costs. Ultimately, life cycle costs are the concept of paying more money for a product on day one but in exchange, reasonably expecting the product to last longer or provide fewer problems during ownership.
We can now apply the same premise to metal roofing panels with a better understanding of life cycle costs. The table below highlights that life cycle costs are a game-changer in any cost comparison between shingle and metal roofing.
Recommended Reading: How Often Does The Roof Need To Be Replaced
Cost Of Roof Repairs And Maintenance
Metal roofs are low-maintenance, but that doesnt mean you can leave them alone for 50 years and expect them to stay in good shape. They do need some occasional maintenance and rare though they may be roof repairs.
Possible repair and maintenance needs for standing seam metal roofs:
- Oil canning: Caused by mistakes in the installation or manufacturing process, oil canning gives metal panels a wavy appearance. Dont worry too much about oil canning, as it doesnt affect the function of your roof. The annoying thing about oil canning is that theres no way to fix it once the panels are installed. The wavy appearance might go away after the metal has a few years to settle, or it might not. Oil canning is less visible in roofs with light colors and low-gloss finishes.
- Leaks: Metal roofs dont spring leaks often, but loosening seams or panels can sometimes cause leaks. Repairs could range from sealing two panels back together to replacing a whole panel if its faulty or warped. Replacing an entire panel will cost a few hundred dollars because you have to pay for the material and labor.
- Cleaning: If you want your metal roof to last as long as it possibly can, have it professionally cleaned at least every few years. Metal roof cleaning usually involves a high-pressure wash, which costs about $0.20 to $0.70 per square foot.
Pros of standing seam metal roofing:
Cons of standing seam metal roofing:
So Should You Get A Metal Roof Or Asphalt Shingle
Only you know if its a great choice for your housing style or your region, but we think theres a case for metal roofs in nearly every town in North America.
If youre planning on selling your home in the next five to 10 years, youll make up to 6% more on resale value with a metal roof versus an asphalt roof. Granted, if youre in a windstorm or wildfire region, your roof needs to stay intact that long for that to compute, but having a metal roof is a great step in that direction.
But all we can say about metal roofs and their cost effectiveness is that you really do get what you pay for. With pro installation, a high-quality metal roof is conceivably expected to last over 60 years Thats 35 to 60 years of reduced energy costs, potential energy savings, and low maintenance. You can bet that adds up, too.
Also Check: Install Ondura Roof Panels
How Much Does A Metal Roof Cost In Kansas City
As metal roofs pop up more and more around Kansas City, were hearing the question asked, How much does a metal roof cost in Kansas City? Today we want to lay some ground work for answering that question, so you can walk into your decision with a solid understanding of what options work best for your home goals.
When discussing the cost of a new roof, we need to take a broader view of all the options.
Estimate Your Metal Roof Cost
Standing Seam Panel calculator1)2)3)“simple”“medium”4)5)LowMid – rangeHigh – end
Note: Costs listed above are based on contractors’ prices in our Local Roofers Directory, and 706,052 roofing projects estimated by RoofCalc.org. Installation prices vary by state .$4.5-6 per square foot $7.2 – 7.5 per square foot$9+ per square foot$8-14 per square foot.
Read Also: Should I Replace The Screws On My Metal Roof
What Is The Cost Of A New Roof And Gutters
The total cost to get your roof and gutters replaced is $9,540 on a 1,500 square foot home. The average cost of new gutters is going to be close to $1,060 for 160 feet of gutters, or $3.60 to $28 per foot. Installing an asphalt roof on the same 1,500 square foot house with an average pitch of 6/12 will average $8,480, including the cost to remove the old roof.
Energy Efficiency And Eco
As homeowners become more aware of the wider environmental effects of heating and cooling their homes, many begin to prioritize efficiency as both a means of saving money and protecting the environment. Metal is a highly reusable material, with many metal roofs being made of about 30%60% recycled metal. Their high durability also means they dont need to be replaced as often, whereas torn and damaged asphalt shingles end up in the landfill.
Additionally, since most metal roofs are reflective, they direct the heat of the sun away from the building they cover, blocking heat and lowering cooling costs. Even non-reflective metal can be treated with special paint that blocks UV rays. Experts typically estimate that youll save about 20%30% off the cost of cooling your home in the summer with a metal roof.
Also Check: How To Extend A Metal Roof Overhang
Standing Seam Metal Roofing System
Standing seam metal roofing system with concealed fasteners.
Standing seam metal roofs are the most traditional form of metal roofing but have the most modern look because of their sharp and clean lines. Popularized by modern architects, the standing seam roof has made a huge comeback in the last decade as the specified roof for custom built and luxury homes in Ontario. The name standing seam refers to the distinct raised vertical seams that lock one panel to the next. Each panel runs continuously from the roofs eave all the way up to the ridge providing maximum protection from wind, rain, ice and snow. There are 2 main types of standing seam used locally, Mechanical Lock and Snap Lock which refers to the method used to lock one seam to the adjacent panel.
|Up to 100 Years||$25.00-$35.00|
*Zinc, Copper and Weathering Steel are considered specialty metals and can come in a wider range of gauge or thickness. Price variance will be more considerable as the price/tonne of raw material is far greater than steel and aluminum. Metal roofing suppliers will need to check prices for these daily rather than list static prices.
How Much Does A New Metal Roof Cost
A metal roof is more expensive to build than a standard asphalt shingle roof, but it has many benefits. According to Modernize, Metal roof costs for homeowners will vary from $6 to $20 per square footage, based on the form of metal roofing installed.
Steel metal roof construction is the most expensive, and it costs an average of $35,516 on a $1,800 square foot home.
Other metal types, as discussed below, can be much less expensive. The cost of metal continues to rise each year, so expect to pay more if you dont take action on your new roof now, compared to later. The different quality of metal can also dictate your expected costs.
Read Also: Add Overhang To Shed
Galvalume Metal Roofing Prices
Galvalume metal costs $0.75 to $2.50 per square foot and starts at $5.50 per square foot installed. Galvalume is a combination of steel, aluminum, zinc, and silicone. A wide range of color options is available.
Galvalume metal roof panels typically last around 60 years however, they have a propensity to completely degrade when in contact with other metals like copper or iron, or other building materials like concrete, brick, or the treated wood found in decks. Also, unless treated with KJynar coatings, galvalumes finish can fade in color or develop a buildup of a chalk-like residue, as well as oil canning, which changes the look of the metal.
Metal Roof Installation In Halifax
You need proper Metal Roofing Halifax installation when it comes to getting your new roof in place. That is why you need the expert roofing contractors at Elite Roofing Halifax. We can help you with all of your metal roof installation needs in Halifax, and surrounding areas. Get a free quote from our team today and lets get started on your metal roofing project.
Disclaimer: This article intends to offer general knowledge on this topic. While every caution has been taken to provide accurate information, it does not intend as professional advice. Please consult with an industry professional in your area to obtain proper advice based on your unique circumstances. Elite Roofing Halifax and its parent company will not be held liable in any way should you suffer any loss/damage because of the information in this blog.
Read Also: Rv Rubber Roof Repair Kit