Wednesday, November 29, 2023
HomeTrendingIs Synthetic Roof Underlayment Better Than Felt

Is Synthetic Roof Underlayment Better Than Felt

Can You Put Shingles On Without Tar Paper

Roofing 101 Synthetic vs Paper Felt Underlayment

Manufacturer warranties and building codes may even call for felt paper to be installed on a roof under the shingles. Chances are a professional roof installation would be fine without the use of felt paper if other measures were taken, though any job would be safer for roofers if felt paper were part of the project.

Synthetic Is More Robust To Extreme Events

The same high winds that blow shingles off can blow underlayment off. Felt paper tears easily enough that wind can catch it and carry it off the roof. Synthetic underlayment, however, comes in much larger rolls and has excellent tear strength. Where a storm could rip felt paper off a roof, it is very unlikely to do the same to synthetic underlayment.

Performance in extreme events is one of the primary functions of underlayment. Shingles handle almost all the weathering, but when outlier events cause water to bypass the shingles, underlayment is designed to shed it. If felt also performs poorly in some extreme events, then it doesnt function as intended.

Synthetic Roof Underlayment Vs Felt: A Comparison Guide To Underlayments

The quality, integrity, and value of roofing are as important as the crown of kings. They serve as vertical covers from the elements of snow, rain, wind, and sun. Moreover, they also determine the aesthetic appeal, habitability, and the shade of structures.

Underlayments, such as synthetic and felt, are those lower layer materials applied to the roof carcass , preceding the final roofing materials used to finish the roof properly. They play a key role in contributing to the prevention of moisture penetration, stability, safety and strength of roof members. Underlays also improve acoustic prowess by limiting noise from external factors like rain.

Moreover, underlayments are always a requirement by roof manufacturers irrespective of quality and type. They enhance the performance outputs of roof installations, provide plane uniform levels to resist sagging, enhance safety, and minimize the cost implications of workforce pressure on roof members, which negatively affects expensive roof materials in the application process.

Read Also: How To Build A Living Roof

Length Width And Weight

Another advantage to synthetic underlayment is that there is more material per roll. Theyre typically four feet wide, which means they cover about 1,000 square feet of roofing deck. This contrasts to traditional felt rolls, which are normally three feet wide and cover about 400 square feet.

This is one of those advantages that is often understated. Synthetic underlayment is lighter, and the rolls cover more of the rooftop, which means its much easier and faster to install and it requires fewer trips up and down ladders to get it on the roof.

How much lighter is synthetic underlayment compared to roofing felt? On average, synthetics weigh about 23 pounds per 10 square feet of material whereas for the same coverage, roofing felt weighs 130 pounds.

All The Facts Roofing Pros Need To Know About Synthetic Underlayment

Why Synthetic Felt Performs Better than 15 lb Felt

by Rick Miller | Nov 19, 2020 | Roofing Underlayment |

Roofing felt has been around for a long time. More than 170 years ago, prospectors covered their shanty roofs with roofing felt, which was known as felt paper or tar paper back then. And it served as the primary roofing material, too, not just an underlayment. Technology evolved over the years, and roofing felt changed, becoming an underlayment beneath shingles and other types of roofing. And technology continues to evolve, which is why we now have synthetic underlayments that are even better than old-fashioned roofing felt.

What makes synthetic underlayment better? Read below and youll find all the facts you need to know!

Also Check: How Much Should A Shingle Roof Cost

Synthetic Underlayment Weight Vs Mil Thickness

Non adhesive synthetic roofing underlayment isn’t created equally. There are lots of high quality synthetic roof underlayment brands , but there are also some low quality brands. They try to trick you with a lousy product and fancy marketing.

The weight of the synthetic underlayment is a great indication of the quality of the underlayment. The membrane layer is where you get your water proofing and abrasion resistance. In an effort to save money, there are brands of synthetic underlayment that boast about their mil thickness. This can be misleading though as some of these underlayment have a fuzzy top layer for walkability thats a false indicator of the materials thickness.

We suggest that you look at the weight of the underlayment instead of the mil thickness to ensure that you have the best synthetic roof underlayment.

How Long Can Roof Underlayment Be Left Exposed

The durability of synthetic underlayment makes it perfect for use on a roof that is not going to be installed immediately as material will not be harmed from exposure to weather conditions. Depending on the underlayment, it can remain exposed anywhere from 2 months up to 30 months and will still remain watertight. Since the material doesn’t absorb moisture, it keeps from wrinkling which would ultimately compromise the finished look of the roof.

Synthetic underlayment also provides better traction for roofers than roofing felt in both wet and dry conditions, making it a safer product to work with during installation.

Read Also: How To Measure A Shingle Roof

What Is The Best Roofing Underlayment For Metal Roof

Metal roofs offer outstanding waterproofing properties, this roof type is affordable, and it wont take forever to roof a building if metal is chosen.

Which type of underlayment will get you the most protection and bang for your buck? Just about anything on the market, according to professionals.

Rule of thumb is that if its manufactured to be installed under tile roofs, it can be used beneath a metal roof, too.

However, if you had to choose one material type of underlaymet for metal roofs, then synthetic underlayment is the best choice compared to the asphalt types of products.

Metal roof underlayment products usually consist of three layers. The first serves as an ice and water shield that is likely made of rubberized-asphalt or butyl-based adhesive with a polyethylene carrier sheet.

The second layer is commonly a reinforced polypropylene scrim thats constructed of multiple layers to add a moisture barrier.

The third layer, an essential for homes with metal roofs in areas where the climate is hot, offers reflective or breathing insulation properties that mediate heat build-up, so its diffused.

One word of caution if youre deciding between underlayments for your roof: be sure to choose one that wont scratch those metal roof panels.

Choosing The Right Type Of Synthetic Underlayment For Your Metal Roof

Roofing Underlayment: Synthetic vs Felt

When you need a reliable underlayment that will last longer for your roof installation, you want to choose synthetic.Synthetic underlayment is the right choice when youre looking for:

  • Easy installation. This material is lightweight and saferto walk on than felt, making for an easier installation.
  • Smoother appearance from laying flatter on the roof decking.
  • Resistance to mold and mildew.
  • Durability. Synthetic underlayment can withstand exposure to the elements for weeks or even months.

If youve decided on synthetic, there are different options to choose from. Continue on to learn about the different types of synthetic underlayment.

Recommended Reading: How Much Would A New Roof Cost

Reasons To Use Syntheticunderlayment

To decide which underlayment is the optimum choice for your project, you first have to understand the actual uses of underlayment and what they can and cannot do:

  • Water resistance
  • Protection from resins in the decking that can be damaging the asphalt shingles
  • Vapor protection
  • Temporary protection in the event of storm damage

Not every home needs the best roof underlayment available on the market and not every budget can afford it. A standard asphalt shingle installation does not require the same vapor protection that might be needed for a metal or slate roof, but a steep roof installation might be safer with the better walking surface provided by some synthetic underlayment.

A common misconception by homeowners is that underlayment is waterproof and that their roof will leak without it. While underlayment is resistant to water, it is not self-sealing, so water can penetrate at every nail hole. So, which underlayment is better for your application?

For more information on synthetic underlayment for roofing, contact us today!

Question: Contractor Says He Used A Double Layer Of Felt On A Low Slope Mobile Home Roof How Do I Know

Great site! I have a doublewide mobile that the contractor says he put double felt on. I was not on site that day.

Roof is now coverded in 30 year composite shingle. The city inspector says it’s a single layer of felt.

With flashing all around the edge of the roof I’m wondering where he’s looking? Contractor is standing by his statement.

Without opening up this roof, how do I tell which story is true? – Reader T.L., Tacoma WA by private email 2017/11/06

Reply: Check the gable end edges of the roof

It’s possible that your city inspector saw something that you didn’t. Perhaps drip edge is installed only on the lower edges and not at the roof eaves.

But it’s easy to determine if there is just a single layer vs double-coverage installation of roofing felt by observing the amount of overlap of the roofing felt plies. My illustration above, adapted from Steve Bliss’s Best Construction Practices is discussed in more detail at ROOFING UNDERLAYMENT BEST PRACTICES.

To inspect for the presence double-coverate roofing felt you’d need to inspect a representative area of the roof that’s accessible such as at a gable end or at the eaves .

Working with care with a flat bar , gently lift the shingles and felt up from the sheathing to see the number of felt layers.

My photo of an asphalt roof installation in process shows that the contractor has installed a peel-and-stick waterproof “ice and water shield” type product along the roof eaves in a 36″ wide strip.

Don’t Miss: Can Solar Panels Damage My Roof

So Which Product Is The Better Choice

Both synthetic, and felt, underlayments have advantages, and disadvantages. As explained above. The deciding factor between the two usually comes down to budget. Because, who wouldnt want the nicer material on their roof if they understood what it was?

Certain roofing companies only use synthetic underlayment on their roofs. So, by choosing to do business with them, you are choosing to have synthetic underlayment. Which isnt a bad thing.

Certain Building Code Prohibits Synthetic Roof Underlayment

Synthetic Roof Underlayment Vs Felt: The Ultimate Comparison

Before making any decision regarding roof underlayment, make sure you or your roofing contractor refer to the building code. Building code will specify not only if underlayment is required, but also what underlayment should be used. Its a rarity, but there are some instances where synthetic roof underlayment will be prohibited and felt underlayment will have to be used.

Recommended Reading: How Often To Get Roof Replaced

Felt Paper Vs Synthetic Underlayment For Your Roof

As an integral part of any roofing system, underlayment provides another waterproof layer of protection from the elements. Installed on top of the decking, but under the shingles, underlayment is in place to keep any water that gets past the shingles away from the decking. It also acts as a weather barrier until the shingles can be installed.

In our industry, there are two main varieties of underlayment: felt paper and synthetic. Felt paper, also referred to as tar paper, was the standard underlayment material in roofing for decades. It was easy to use, durable, and even had alignment lines to help with the shingle installation.

Synthetic underlayment started gaining popularity in the last decade. Lighter than felt, synthetic underlayment is just as easy to work with and is just as durable if not more so than felt paper. Both types of underlayment are used in roughly the same way but may be attached to the decking differently.

So which one is best? It depends on who you ask. So lets take a closer look at the differences between these two materials.

To Better Cope With Temperature Extremes

Every year, communities in Bergen, Passaic, Essex and other northern NJ counties witness highs above 90 degrees F and lows well below freezing. Over time, the organic substances in regular roof felt can dry out and turn brittle. By contrast, the inert substances in synthetic materials are resistant to temperature extremes.

Recommended Reading: Can I Put A Deck On My Flat Roof

Synthetic Vs Felt Underlayment For Metal Roofing: Which Is Best

There are distinct differences between synthetic and asphalt-saturated felt underlayment used for metal roofing systems. Stay educated on the advantages and disadvantage of these two popular underlayment options.

What is roofing underlayment?

What are the most common types?

What are the pros and cons of the options?

Whether youre a property owner looking into your roofing underlayment options or a contractor merely staying educated on underlayments, these are just a few of the questions you might be asking yourself.

When it comes to metal roofing, there are two main options for underlayment: Synthetic or felt paper. Both are good choices to use for metal roofing, but there are some distinct differences to keep in mind.

At Sheffield Metals, weve spent 20 years offering complete engineered metal roofing systems, including the underlayment, for our customers to install. Thats why we think its vital to discuss:

  • What synthetic underlayment is
  • The advantages and disadvantages of synthetic
  • What felt underlayment is
  • The advantages and disadvantages of felt

Synthetic Vs Felt Roofing Underlayment: Pros & Cons

Why Tri-Flex® is better than felt

When most people think of roofs, they typically think of shingles or metal roofing. But what some may not know is theres another layer of protection directly on top of the roof deck and under the roof covering that performs a critical role in protecting your home from moisture damage. Its called roofing underlayment.

Find out more about this critical component to your roofs structure.

You May Like: How Much To Repair A Trailer Roof

The Right Underlayment Foryour Roof

Whether youre embarking on a reroofing project or new home construction, there are many factors to consider about the type of underlayment to use. Synthetic roofing underlayment has many advantages over felt and may be a worthwhile investment to protect your roof and home from the risks of water and moisture infiltration.

Learn more about our selection of roofing underlayment products and find an independent roofing contractor in the Owens Corning Roofing Contractor Network near you.

*9 rolls of standard #30 felt compared to 2 rolls of Owens Corning® Deck Defense® High-Performance Synthetic Underlayment. Individual product weights may vary.

Cons Of Synthetic Underlayment

There really arent many disadvantages to choosing synthetic underlayment over felt. The initial price may be an issue for some budget-conscious homeowners, but the trade-off is an underlayment that is durable, longer lasting, and more weather resistant than felt.

Synthetic underlayment is a great choice if durability, ease of use, and improved weather resistance is important to you for your roofing project. While it may be more expensive initially, it will save you money in the long run in increased protection.

Also Check: How To Rid Moss On Roof

Which Roof Underlayment Weighs More

Felt underlayment weighs more than synthetic underlayment. You probably dont think the weight of the material is an important comparison.

However, the weight of your roof underlayment is going to impact the labor cost of your roof replacement. Theres one main reason why the heavier product adds to the labor cost.

Because felt underlayment is a heavy roofing material, it doesnt have as much material per roll as synthetic. This leads to needing more of it, which takes more time and manpower to get it up the ladder and install it on your roof.

While this wont add too much to your labor costs, its just something to keep in mind.

Felt Is Not Compatible With Top Warranties

RhinoRoof Synthetic Roofing Underlayment

Manufacturers tend to require synthetic underlayment when providing upgraded warranties. Manufacturers tend to allow only their best contractors to provide upgraded warranties, which means that if you want a quality contractor, youre probably looking for a contractor that uses synthetic underlayment. Even if traditional felt was better than synthetic underlayment, if all the contractors that do the quality work use synthetic, it would mean opting for an installation with felt would more likely result in a lower quality job.

Also Check: How Do I Estimate The Cost Of A New Roof

What Roof Underlayment Should I Use

Felt underlayment is recommended when:

  • Cost is the main concern. Felt is the more affordable underlayment solution.
  • Building code requires the use of felt underlayment.

Synthetic underlayment is recommended when you are looking for:

  • Underlayment that will last the longest.
  • Easy installation. This material is lightweight and saferto walk on than felt.
  • Smoother appearance from laying flatter on the roof decking.
  • Resistance to mold and mildew.
  • Durability. Synthetic underlayment can withstand exposure to the elements for weeks or even months.

At Western States Metal Roofing, we have been in the roofing manufacturing industry for over 20 years. We understand how important using quality products is to having a successful roof installation and we take pride in the products we offer.

Choosing the right underlayment for your roof can be confusing. Our team is happy to answer any questions you have. We have roofing underlayment ready to be shipped immediately in addition to all of our other roofing products and accessories. We can also provide you with a free quote for any of our products.

If you are researchingunderlaymentfor ametal roofthen these two videos will be helpful:

What Is Asphalt Felt/tar Paper Underlayment

Asphalt felt underlayment is known by many different names, including felt paper, roofing tar paper, felt underlayment, asphalt-soaked felt, and so on. For this article, we will just call it felt underlayment or felt paper. Felt underlayment is an all-over roofing accessory made of a natural or synthetic base that is then saturated in asphalt to make it waterproof. It is then laid down and attached to the roof deck below the roofing material.

Felt paper was widely used in the mid-to-late 1900s as the preferred underlayment choice but is slowly phasing out due to new and improved product developments . However, it is still used today in steep slope and shingle applications.

Also Check: How To Install A Cupola On A Metal Roof


Most Popular