Sunday, April 21, 2024
HomePopularAre Tin Roofs More Expensive Than Shingles

Are Tin Roofs More Expensive Than Shingles

Disadvantages Of Choosing Metal Roofing

Angie’s List Metal Roofs

Higher One-Time Cost Its true, metal roofing is more expensive than shingle roofing as a one-time cost. In addition to the higher cost of materials, there also could be a higher price point for labor and the equipment needed to complete the job, though its dependent on where the installers are getting the metal panels.

Limited Qualified Contractors Finding a qualified and experienced metal roofing contractor or installer will make or break an installation, especially since nearly all potential problems with metal roofing stem from some kind of installer error. When compared to shingle roofing installers, there are significantly fewer installers who are equipped and skilled at installing metal roofing.

More Labor Intensive Metal roofing is a precision installation that is much less forgiving than a shingle roof installation. There is virtually zero room to make errors, which is why metal roofing must be installed by a trained craftsperson. This typically means its a little more of a labor-intensive process that could take up more time.

Municipality Issues There are some communities or Home Owners Associations that do not allow metal roofing to be installed on a new or existing home within its jurisdiction. Common reasons for the ban:

  • Metal is often thought of as looking industrial
  • Inconsistent or goes against the look of a neighborhood
  • Can have high-glare issues

Asphalt Shingle Roofs Generally Are Easier To Install And Repair

The installation process is an important parameter for some homeowners who are on strict timelines. If you want a quick roof installed, shingles are the choice for you. They can be installed in a day or two. In some cases, they can also be installed on an existing layer. Metal roofing on the other hand takes more time because of the specialized installation system. However, there are some lightweight varieties of metal roofs that can be installed right over an existing roof and that may take lesser time. If you have to replace metal roofs, that may be a longer and more complex process because of the way the panels are attached.

The pros of metal roofs often overpower their cons making it an obvious choice for homeowners. However, it is advised to take advice from a professional for your particular home. Now that you know various distinguishing qualities of metal roofs vs shingles, its time to choose the right company to get a hassle-free installation.

Metal Roof Vs Shingles: Which Is Better For My Home

This content is from our sponsor. The FOX editorial team was not involved with the creation of this content.

When it comes time to install a new roof, its easy to grow overwhelmed by the options available.

Asphalt shingle roofing has been the dominant choice for residential homes for a long time, but more recently, metal roofing has surged in popularity. Metal shingles, metal panels, and other metal roofing options that imitate tile, wood, slate, and even asphalt can make it incredibly difficult to choose whats best for your home.

Both options have their own list of pros and cons, so before you decide what to use for your roof and make a long-term investment, lets do a comparison: metal roof vs. shingles.

Recommended Reading: How Much Roof Overhang On Shed

Metal Roofing Vs Shingle Roofing: Which Material Should You Choose

Metal roofing and shingle roofing are both viable options to choose for your next roofing project, but there are distinct benefits, drawbacks, and differences to know of before you buy.

If youre in the market for a new roof, you might be questioning the type of roof that will work best for you and your home or building. And while its great to have so many options, such as asphalt shingles, metal, wood, tile, or concrete, it can also be overwhelming to weigh all the advantages and disadvantages of each type of roofing material.

Luckily, theres not just one answer for every building, which gives you the freedom to discover the available options, ask any and all questions, and finally make a choice based on factual research.

Here at Sheffield Metals, we think its important to give an honest comparison of everything you need to know about metal roofing systems and asphalt shingle roofing so the decision is easier for you. In this article, expect to learn about:

  • The advantages and disadvantages of metal roofing
  • The advantages and disadvantages of asphalt shingles
  • Important considerations to keep in mind before you choose

Metal Roof Vs Shingles Resale Value

The Most Energy Efficient And Economical Roofing Types ...

Asphalt shingles tend to have a higher resale value than metal roofs. In 2020, a roof replacement with asphalt shingles yielded a return on investment of 65.9% nationwide, but one with a metal roof only 61.2%. Keep in mind that the ROI for a metal roof replacement has increased since last year, but the rate for asphalt shingle roofing has decreased, so metal roofs may surpass asphalt ones in the coming years.

The resale value of your roof depends on the potential homebuyers’ preferences. They may appreciate a metal roof’s energy efficiency, long lifespan, resistance to weather damage and unique aesthetic. On the other hand, if the buyer doesn’t prefer your roof’s color and style, you might not get a higher offer on your property based on how it looks next to the other houses on your block.

Prospective buyers may enjoy the reliable, low-maintenance asphalt shingles on your house. Architectural shingles tend to have a higher ROI than traditional asphalt shingles because of their additional protection against weather damage. However, if the buyer wants a unique roof, they may skip over your house because it looks like every other property in the neighborhood.

You May Like: How To Build An Overhang

The Full Scoop Lets Compare A 30 X 30 Garage Roof

Both metal and asphalt roofing get the job done when it comes to sheltering a building, but they really part ways in respect to durability, energy efficiency, and long-term savings.

Lets look at a 30 x 30 garage for an example. But before we go any further, lets just clarify that the example and prices are not meant to be an official quote. The numbers in our example are for informational purposes only but are accurate to the best of our knowledge. Every roof project is different. Rest assured we have a dedicated and knowledgeable team that would be happy to get you a custom quote.

On the surface, an asphalt shingle roof is the slim winner at $1,194 versus $1,267 for an ABM Panel metal roof . But if you look at the bigger picture, metal is the obvious choice. The Asphalt Roofing Manufacturers Association states on their website, If a residential roof is more than 20 years old, it is a prime candidate for reroofing.

Compare that to our ABM Panel that comes with 40-year paint warranty. There is no question that a metal roof can stand the test of time better than asphalt shingles in most situations, and contractors will tell you that there is very little keeping a properly maintained metal roof from lasting over 100 years . Metal lasts longer, is more energy efficient, is more beautiful, and can cost about the same as asphalt shingles.

Lets take a closer look at the cost.

Metal Roofing Trends For 2022

Metal Roofing Trends for 2022 from RRG Roofing. Roofs have been necessary to man for generations. Even though your forefathers emerged from underground, we have been building our dwellings. We rarely ceased learning about new roofer concepts and components. Metals as asphalt shingles revolutionized the art of building.

You understand that metal covering will be the first defense between your property and Mother Earth. Originally, roofs were just for protection from the sun and rain. The roof is becoming a significant design component. Residential roofing shingles come in a wide range of styles. It is the main reason why roofs are so standard in the United States.

Also Check: Adding Eaves To Gable End

Metal Roof Shingles Buying Guide

Metal roof shingles cost $11,000-14,000 installed on a 1,600 sq.ft. ranch style home. A metal roof is an ideal option for people who plan to stay in their home for many years.

Metal shingles is a premium roofing material that offers exceptional style, durability and longevity.

If you are ready to install a new metal shingles roof, contact your local roofing pros for FREE ESTIMATES!

Metal Roofing Cost Vs Premium Materials

Why you may want to consider installing a metal roof

Since metal is considered a high-end material, it makes sense to compare its cost to other premium roofs, such as cedar shingles, slate, synthetic slate, clay and concrete tile.

Roofing Material
$7 14 20 40 years

Looking at the price difference vs benefits derived from high-end roofs, it is clear that a metal roof offers the best value.

Read Also: How Much For Shingle Roof

Frequently Asked Questions About Metal Shingles

Here are the answers to some of the most questions homeowners have when they are considering installing a metal shingle roof on their house.

Can you walk on metal shingles?

Its possible to walk on metal shingles, if your roof is not too steep. Also, keep in mind, that metal shingles will be slippery after it rains, so its best to avoid walking on the roof at that time.

Overall, its best to ask a roofing pro to come check out your metal roof if there is an issue with it, instead of walking on it yourself, unless you have experience with safely walking on a roof.

Will a metal roof make my house hotter?

You dont need to worry about excessive heat inside your home with a metal roof. In fact, the opposite will happen a metal roof will actually make your house cooler.

This is because most metal shingles come with special coatings that repel sun rays, making your home more energy efficient.

A classic dark color asphalt roof will heat up in the sun and retain heat a lot more than a metal roof.

For maximum energy efficiency, consider installing a lighter metal roofing color.

Does a metal roof interfere with cellular service/wifi signal?

You dont have to worry that installing metal shingles will cause trouble to your cell phone or internet signal. There is absolutely no evidence of a metal roof causing such issues.

How long will metal shingles last?

With quality installation, you can be sure that your metal shingles roof will last at least 40-50 years.

Consider The Whole Picture


Aluminum panels are typically produced from 90% or more recycled content. Steel panels vary by supplier, but usually contain at least 10% recycled content. Both types of metal will last for decades and are 100% recyclable after use.

Asphalt shingles, on the other hand, are produced from petroleum products and are typically 19-36% asphalt by weight. Asphalt shingles have to be torn off and replaced every 15-25 years. Approximately 11 million tons of asphalt shingles are discarded each year, with most being sent to landfills.

Property Insurance

Many insurers offer discounts for metal roofing sometimes connected with hail or wind performance rating. Since programs will vary by insurer and location, check with your local agent.

Energy Efficiency

While asphalt shingles will absorb and retain heat from the sun, metal panels will reflect and emit heat away, resulting in lower cooling costs. Several studies by the Florida Solar Energy Center indicate a reduction in cooling costs between 10 and 25%. As always, individual results will vary.

Lifecycle Costs

Strong in the Storm

Of course no roof can completely withstand all the force of nature. However, studies and damage reports conducted by/for FEMA, NHC/NOAA, and FBC over the years consistently indicate that shingle damage from hurricanes is fairly common, while metal roofs tend to perform very well.

Also Check: Add Overhang To Side Of House

Metal Roof Material Costs

The type of metal used for the install is the main cost factor after labor. The price of metal ranges from an average per square foot price of $1.60 for Galvalume to $22.50 for copper. Contractors will factor in the heaviness of the metal usedits harder to work with heavy materials that dont cut easily.

The secondary most significant cost is underlayment which will add $30 to $50 to the cost of materials. You may be offered upgrade options for the underlayment, with prices between $4 to $5.50 per square foot installed, or $1 to $3 for felt. Items like fasteners, screws, rivets, clamps or clips, plywood or roof deck materials, flashings or pipe boots, sealants or butyl tape are essential components of your installation.

Metal Roofing Installed Over Shingles

How To Know When Your Roof Shingles Are Ready To Mingle ...

According to Union Corrugating, most roof types simply weigh too much to be installed over top of one another without adding additional structural support to the roof. Roofs are designed to support a predetermined amount of weight and the installation of subsequent layers of heavy roofing materials such as asphalt roofing shingles can cause structural damage. In these cases, removing the old asphalt roofing shingles is usually recommended, but this creates a large amount of landfill waste. In fact, asphalt roofing shingles make up over 3% of all municipal solid waste, or 6.8 million tons annually. Installing metal roofing over shingles can help solve these issues.

Because metal roofs are so light yet so strong, metal roofing panels can typically be easily installed over your existing asphalt roof shingles without the need to add structural reinforcement. The old asphalt roof shingles under the metal roof simply serve as an extra layer of insulation and water protection and pose no problems to the new metal roof. Of course, each metal roofing over shingles installation is different, so consult your licensed metal roofing contractor to confirm if your roof is suitable for a metal roofing over shingles installation.

metal roof, light yet so strong

· Tricounty Metals

Don’t Miss: Should I Replace The Screws On My Metal Roof

Is There A Metal Roof Insurance Discount

If you live in a region that has frequent hail storms such as Texas then you’re more likely to receive an insurance discount when compared to someone that lives in California. However, it’s dependent upon the insurance company. Let’s call this a “maybe” and call your insurance company to see if you qualify for a policy discount.

Slate Tile Roofing Shingles

Slate roofing shingles are a stone roofing material that is installed as a shingle. Slate shingles are thin but very heavy when the whole roof is made out of them. Slate has a natural beauty to it that many people appreciate, but the shingles do not really vary in color or looks. Slate roofing shingles cost on average $8 to $14 per square foot or $800 to $1,400 per square to install. Slate tiles are more difficult to install but when done properly they will give you one of the longest-lasting roof options available. Slate shingles come with an expensive price tag, but that does not mean that slate is not a great roof type option if you can afford it. Many people decide slate roofs are worth the cost to install since they will last more than a lifetime from 60 to 150 years.

You May Like: How To Repair A Trailer Roof

Is A Metal Roof Better Than Shingles

Lets start off by clarifying that both materialsasphalt shingles and metal roofingare great options for residential roofing. Both will protect your home and should last for many years. However, one or the other might be better suited to your needs and preferences.

Asphalt shingles remain to be the most popular material for roofing residential properties and are available in a wide array of colors and textures. Standard, three-tab shingles are most commonly used, though laminated and architectural asphalt shingles are also available. A matting or fiberglass core, an asphalt coating, and a stone or ceramic surface make for a highly durable shingle.

Alternatively, metal roofing tends to be lightweight, as well as durable and energy efficient. It also comes in a variety of designs which makes for a versatile and therefore appealing product. But what are their specific pros and cons and which roof is best for your home?

Is Steel Roofing Better Than Shingles

Installing the Metal Roof

Whether you are looking for a new roof for a new home or in the market for replacing an old one, you might have doubts of steel roof is better than shingles?

  • Style: Modern metal roofs come in a variety of colours and styles which gives you an opportunity to style it to match your exterior design. Asphalt shingles are not that much versatile.
  • Cost: As for the steel roofing cost yes, it is more expensive than asphalt shingles. However, when you look at the life-cycle costing, you will see that it is much more budget-efficient to invest in something more durable and reliable as a steel roof. Steel roofing will last you from 40 70 years with occasional care compared to 12-20 years of asphalt shingles.
  • Energy Efficient: A steel roof will reflect the rays of the sun, thus keeping your home cool on hot days. Your new steel roof will keep money in your pocket by reducing your air conditioning costs by 10-15%. The roof that keeps on giving! In contrast, heat goes literally through asphalt shingle.
  • Durable: Protect your home from harsh Toronto weather with steel roofing. Compared to asphalt shingles, steel is: able to withstand winds, will not crack against impact, and will not ignite due to fires or lightning. Best of all, this means that your roof will not require as much maintenance like other roofing materials!

In other words, it is a validated decision replacing a shingle roof with a steel roof.

RELATED ARTICLE: Pros and Cons of Metal Roofing

You May Like: Large Overhang Roof


Most Popular