Monday, June 3, 2024
HomeShinglesWhich Is Better Shingles Or Metal Roof

Which Is Better Shingles Or Metal Roof

Is An Asphalt Shingle Roof Or A Metal Roof Right For You

Busting common MYTHS about Metal Roofing!

An asphalt roof is going to be more cost-effective and you get great warranty options, but it has a shorter lifespan and needs more maintenance.

A metal roof system is going to be more expensive, but lives longer and requires less maintenance. However, I would only recommend a standing-seam metal roof over a heated space such as your home or office.

Are you still struggling to make a decision? Do you just want to assure yourself that you’re choosing the right roof? If this sounds like you, take our free Roof Type Quiz to help.

Pros & Cons Of Metal Vs Asphalt Shingle Roofs

When it comes to these two materials, there are categories in which one or the other is clearly the best choice. But, there are also categories in which the choice comes down to preference.

The following guide addresses the advantages and disadvantages of metal roofing in general versus three-tab asphalt shingles. This chart outlines the best options for major considerations and uses.

Which is Better: Metal or Shingle Roof?

Metal is best for
  • Most builders stick with standard colors, textures and shades because they are widely available and low-cost.


Is A Metal Roof Better Than A Shingle Roof

Metal Roof vs Shingles

Metal roofing is able to last twice as long than asphalt shingles yet the latter is cheaper in price. This is because asphalt shingles are the most basic roofing materials out there with only a layer of protection which leaves them more susceptible to repairs.

They are also more susceptible to damages that come with inclement weather and can blow off from strong winds. As of such, asphalt shingles are easier to replace and can be easily obtained in hardware stores while with metal roofing youll have to have an intermediary to order materials from a qualified manufacturer.

With metal roofing, however, your roof is protected from inclement weather and will offer more insulation benefits than with asphalt shingles. Whats more, with metal roofing youll be able to have lower energy costs with its ability to reflect the sun rays.

Asphalt shingles do have lighter pigment options which can offer similar improvements in solar reflection as well.

Recommended Reading: Can Solar Panels Blown Off Roof

If Youre Deciding Between Purchasing A Shingle Roof Or A Metal Roof Then Youre In The Right Place

There is a lot of information online about metal roofs and shingle roofs. But there are so many ways to compare these two roofing types that finding good information from trusted sources would require hours of research. And even then, are you able to find information that compares every aspect of these two options to actually feel comfortable in making a purchase?

Weve taken the time to compile it all together and break down everything you need to know about each roofing type to help make your decision easier.

Were going to discuss

  • What are shingles and metal panels made of?
  • When is it best to use shingles?
  • When is it best to use metal?
  • What are the different types of shingle roofs?
  • What are the different types of metal roofs?
  • What are the pros and cons of a metal roof?
  • What are the pros and cons of a shingle roof?
  • What is the cost of a shingle roof?
  • What is the cost of a metal roof?
  • Which roof has a higher return on investment ?
  • Which roof is best for me?

At Western States Metal Roofing we get asked all about metal roofing. Were a family-owned and operated metal roofing manufacturer and seller for over 25 years. What dont we sell? Shingle roofing.

Purchasing a roof is a major investment. We want you to be thoroughly informed about your choices so you can be confident and excited with the roof you choose.

This guide will answer all of the questions that you have about shingle roofing and metal roofing, and even some that you would have never thought of.

Is A Metal Roof Better Than Shingles

Asphalt Shingles vs. Metal Roofing

Lets start off by clarifying that both materialsasphalt shingles and metal roofingare great options for residential roofing. Both will protect your home and should last for many years. However, one or the other might be better suited to your needs and preferences.

Asphalt shingles remain to be the most popular material for roofing residential properties and are available in a wide array of colors and textures. Standard, three-tab shingles are most commonly used, though laminated and architectural asphalt shingles are also available. A matting or fiberglass core, an asphalt coating, and a stone or ceramic surface make for a highly durable shingle.

Alternatively, metal roofing tends to be lightweight, as well as durable and energy efficient. It also comes in a variety of designs which makes for a versatile and therefore appealing product. But what are their specific pros and cons and which roof is best for your home?

Also Check: How Do You Finance A New Roof

Does Metal Roof Increase Home Value

Metal roofing is more expensive than asphalt shingles and so is deemed more desirable by many buyers, so it will increase the value of a home. The value obviously depends on the style, quality, and to some extent the color, but the return is typically around 70% of the investment. Metal roofing is also more durable, fire resistant, longer lasting and often carries a transferable warranty, all of which contribute to it improving a homes value.

What Are The Different Types Of Shingle Roofs And Metal Roofs

Whether you decide to use either shingles or metal for your roof, youre going to have to also decide on the specific type of shingle or metal roofing panel that will be used.

Both shingle and metal roofing come in different forms that vary in price and quality. When deciding on what to use for your roof, factors such as desired aesthetic, climate, and budget can help narrow down your choice for the right roofing option.

Lets first discuss the different options you have for shingle roofs, then look at your options for metal roofs.

Also Check: Can You Put New Tin Over Old Tin Roof

Can Metal Roofing Be Installed Over Asphalt Shingles

It is common practice to install a new layer of shingles over an existing layer. Since metal roofing is lighter than asphalt shingles, it too can be installed over existing shingles. This means the asphalt shingles dont have to be removed or disposed of. Thus, generating savings in both removal and disposal, and also accelerating the installation of the new roof.

What Factors Affect The Cost Of A Re

Class 4 Shingle Comparison | Owens Corning | Certainteed | Denver Roofers

The geographic region, eave height, and complexity of the roof all impact the cost of roof replacement. But beyond that, product selection, aesthetics, and installation costs are also dominant factors.

Product Type: The broad type of product selected and the family of products within that category significantly impact the cost of any roofing project. So while the first tier decision might be metal or shingles, the second tier decisions include the thickness of the product and style/type of product.

For example, there are two predominant types of metal roofing: concealed fastener and exposed fastener panels. The product and installation costs vary significantly between the two styles. So while exposed fastener panels on straight gable roofs with low eave heights might be priced comparative to asphalt shingles, a concealed fastener system on a two-story house with a complex roof plan might be much more costly.

Aesthetics: Another critical factor in pricing considerations is aesthetics. Metal roofs come in a wide range of finishes and styles. You can even choose a metal roof that looks like slate, shakes, or tile, and, as Todd Miller points out in this article, those styles can be a great way to enhance a home immediately through increased beauty as well as the high end value implication of an upscale home.

Read Also: How Often Should I Replace My Roof

Factors To Consider When Deciding On A Roof

The above are general guidelines for when it’s best to use each type of roof. But we know that every situation is different. So we want to give you some basic questions to consider that should help tailor your decision more to your specific circumstances.

Consider the following questions when deciding on a new roof:

  • What is the budget for my roof?

Shingle roofing has a lower upfront cost than metal. There are options with metal that can make the roof more affordable. We discuss the cost of both roofing materials in detail in Chapter 6.

  • How long am I going to live in my home?

If you plan on being in your home for less than 15 years, it will be more difficult to get the full value of a metal roof.

  • Do I want to install the roof myself?

Shingles are better suited for self installation. While some metal roofs, such as corrugated, are DIY friendly, a shingle roof is the easier and faster material to work with.

  • Does my home have any HOA restrictions on roofing types?

If your home does have an HOA, pay attention to what their guidelines are regarding roofing to make sure your new roof is in compliance.

Whether youre leaning towards metal or shingles, there are still more options in each category to decide on. In the next chapter, we go over the different types of shingle and metal roofing.

Chapter 5

Types Of Corrugated Metal Roofing Panels

Corrugated metal roofing sheets are designed to have grooves and ridges that have an industrial look to them. Below are the most common types of corrugated metal roofing panels on the market.

  • Corrugated: A wavy panel that is wider and has deeper corrugations than ½ corrugated. The waviness is more profound with corrugations and each panel is normally 39 or 37 wide.
  • R-Panel: Consists of squared ribs that are 1.25 in height. R-Panel is the corrugated panel with the closest resemblance to standing seam.
  • 7.2 Panel:Ribbed panel with a boxy appearance. These panels feature symmetrical ribs that are spaced 7.2 on center, with each rib measuring 1.5 high.

Durability Of Corrugated Metal Roofing

Metal roofing materials are durable and can handle high wind gusts. Theyre designed to not crack, chip, or warp. Metal roofs are also resistant to fires, mold, mildew, and termite damage.

The level of durability depends on the gauge, or thickness, of your roof. A thicker roof is a stronger material. As the gauge number gets lower, the thickness increases. Oil canning is inherent in all metal roofs, it is more noticeable on a standing seam roof because of the flat surfaces. The ridges and grooves of corrugated panels help better disguise the waviness of oil canning.

How Long Will A Standing Seam Metal Roof Last?

Standing seam roofs are considered “Lifetime Roofs”, meaning they are designed to last 40 to 60 plus years when installed correctly.

You May Like: When To Replace Roof Tiles

Functional Life Vs Aesthetic Life

There is a difference between the functional life and aesthetic life of an asphalt shingle roof.

Asphalt shingles are a temporary or disposable roof and they have two different life cycles. National studies define the functional life of most roofs at about 17 years. This is quite a bit different than the aesthetic life, which is closer to 5 to 7 years.

The aesthetic life is when the shingles are streaked and stained. The climate has weathered the roof where the shingles look like an old roof. Once they get to that point, even though the roof may continue to protect and perform against the weather, the roof looks like its on its last leg. The roof begins to detract from the homes overall appearance, curb appeal, and property value.

Top Benefits Of Metal Roofing Compared To Shingles

Which Is Better Metal Roofing Or Shingles?
  • Metal roofing is durable and routinely lasts 2-4 times longer than shingles.
  • Homeowners like the idea of buying only one more roof in their life instead of potentially several.
  • Metal roofing outperforms shingles in cases of hail and other severe weather events.
  • Metal roofing is highly reflective and can save 20-40% on electricity bills.
  • Metal roofing has a high recycled content, which helps reduce landfill pressure instead of adding to it like asphalt shingles.
  • Metal roofing looks great, improving curb appeal and resale values.

Given the sharp increase in market share, it seems that more and more homeowners are making performance, not price, their dominant purchase decision.

Learn more about metal roof cost.

Also Check: What Is The Average Warranty For A New Roof

How Long Does Shingle Roofing Last

The lifespan of any roof affects its value. In simple terms, the longer the roof lasts, the more value you get out of it.

The average lifespan of an asphalt shingle roof is 10 to 20 years. However, it can be shorter depending on the climate and pitch of the roof.

Asphalt begins to deteriorate as soon as you expose it to normal weather. While the roof may function for 10-20 years, it usually begins to look weathered and old after 5-7 years.

Metal Roof Vs Shingles: Maintenance

Roof maintenance doesnt top anyones list of fun things to do, yet it must be done to ensure a roofs longevity.

With asphalt shingles, most maintenance involves penetrations through the roof where adhesives, metal flashing and sealants are used. Those sealants deteriorate over time and therefore need to be replaced. And rubber pipe boots the flashings for plumbing pipes that come through the roof are also prone to break down and need attention or replacement.

On a properly installed metal roof, penetrations are flashed with matching metal. If a sealant is used, its as the first line of defense, but the true water tightness comes from the flashing design and the way it channels water off of the roof, Miller says.

On a metal roof, rubber pipe boots are often covered with metal to match the roof, not only for aesthetics, but to protect the soft rubber from the suns damaging rays. That lengthens its life considerably.

Winner: Metal roofing. While maintenance costs for an asphalt shingle roof arent outrageous, a metal roof simply requires less.

Read Also: A And E Metal Roofing

Lower Home Insurance Costs

Hail damage on a shingle roof is a regular occurrence in certain climates. Its one of the leading causes of home insurance claims. In these states there can be insurance policy discounts of up to 30%. Each region and insurance company is different.

We suggest you call your insurance company and ask them if they offer a discount for a metal roof. Get an insurance quote with an asphalt shingle roof and a quote for a metal roof. You can then determine if there is a savings and whether its enough to justify the higher cost of a metal roof.

If you would like a deeper dive into metal roofing insurance discounts check out:

Metal Roof Insurance Discounts: How Much Will I Save?

Are Metal Roofs Better Than Shingle Roofs

DIY – How To Install Metal Roof Shingles (Rustic Shingles) – American Metal Roofs

Metal roofs aren’t better than shingle roofs, but neither are shingles better than metal panels. Your roofing material choice depends on your design preference, budget, environment and long-term goals. To help you navigate all those factors, you can speak with our professionals at

If you need additional protection for the top of your house, our team specializes in roof replacements. We partner with experienced contractors who know how to install all types of roofs, including metal and shingle. For more information about starting the process of installing a new roof, you may contact us online or call 855-560-3765 to get a roof inspection.

You May Like: How To Repair Roof Leak

We Answer: Which Is Better A Metal Roof Or Shingles

From time to time homeowners will face that pivotal roofing fork in the road: Do they go with a metal roof or shingles?

When it comes to replacing your roof and installing a new one, homeowners have several roofing materials that they can choose from. From asphalt shingles to slate, and cedar shake to metal, there is no shortage of selection for adding roof curb appeal.

However, in most cases, the most common roofing materials homeowners find themselves contemplating are metal or asphalt shingles. That is why today, we will review the pros and cons of both, the pricing structure, and hopefully help you answer your question once and for all which is better a metal roof or shingles?

Pricing: Metal Roof Vs Shingles

On average, standing seam metal roofs can cost anywhere from $7-$14 per square foot, whereas architectural asphalt shingles cost $3-$5 per square foot. No matter what roofing material you elect to go with, the prices will vary depending on the material.

The average metal roof price is somewhere in the neighborhood of $18,000 and the average price of a new asphalt shingle roof is approximately $8,500. So if youre on a budget, in most cases people will elect to go with an asphalt shingle roof.

Additionally, in addition to price, factors such as warranties and repairs also matter. Some studies show that over 60 years the prices even out over time. That said, the average person does not live in the same house for longer than 5-10 years. So if you plan on staying for a long time, a metal roof might be worth consideration. However, if you are in a starter home or plan on moving soon, asphalt shingles are typically your best bet.

Note: We have put together this complete roofing shingle pricing guide so you can compare pricing for different types of shingles!

Don’t Miss: How To Replace A Shingle On Your Roof

Is A Metal Roof Cheaper Than Shingles

Metal roofing is growing more and more popular in the roofing industry. This has sparked homeowners to start comparing the more commonly used asphalt shingle roof to metal roofing.

One of the biggest comparison questions we get is, Is a metal roof cheaper than shingles?

The team at Bill Ragan Roofing has over 30 years of experience answering questions just like this one. To ensure homeowners like you make the right purchasing decision, well be breaking down if a metal roof is cheaper than shingles.

Not only will we be comparing metal roof cost to shingle cost, but well also be comparing their lifespans, warranties, and more. By the end of this article, youll know which one is right for you and your replacement.


Most Popular