Look Up Your Community Guidelines
This is a factor that some homeowners don’t consider when choosing between a metal and asphalt roof. Some neighborhoods may adhere to strict design guidelines when it comes to exterior materials. This is particularly true in historically significant areas or communities with a homeowners association.
Metal Roof Vs Asphalt Shingles: Pros & Cons
When it comes time to install a new roof, its easy to grow overwhelmed by the options available.
Asphalt shingle roofing has been the dominant choice for residential homes for a long time, but more recently, metal roofing has surged in popularity.
Metal shingles, metal panels, and other metal roofing options that imitate tile, wood, slate, and even asphalt can make it incredibly difficult to choose whats best for your home.
Both options have their own list of pros and cons, so before you decide what to use for your roof and make a long-term investment, lets do a comparison: metal roof vs. shingles.
Factors To Consider Before Choosing:
Whenever considering a home renovation, it is important to recognize all the factors that can play into your roof replacement. Factors such as the insurance costs, warranties, roofing extras, cost, your HOA requirements, and numerous other items can impact your final decision.
Pricing is important. Quality is important. Ultimately, your decision goes down to what you want and also what youre willing to pay for!
You May Like: Can You Make Payments On A New Roof
Consider Your Environment And Climate
If you live in an area thats prone to extreme heat, high winds and severe storms, metal may be your best option. Metal roofs can take a beating. They withstand the sun’s powerful rays and easily drain rainwater from their surfaces. Studies reveal that properly secured roofs covered with this material can withstand winds up to 140 mph.
A roof covered with asphalt shingles is also durable. Instead of reflecting UV rays, the granules within the coating absorb them. Furthermore, because they’re waterproof, rain and snow quickly flow into gutters. However, asphalt shingles aren’t as wind resistant as metal. When an uplift occurs, the shingles are loosened. So if you live in a windy area, asphalt shingles may not be right for you.
Metal Roofing Problems: 7 Common Issues That Could Affect Your Roof
Knowing about the problems that could occur on a metal roof system will help prevent issues from the very start, resulting in less time and money necessary for repairs.
No product in the world is perfect, no matter how much money its worth or how well its cared for. You could be in a lucky situation where nothing ever goes wrong with something youve purchased or you could experience one or more problems at any given time. It all just depends. Metal roofing is no different.
While there are variables affecting the problems that could occur with a metal roofing system, sometimes things just happen that are beyond human control. This might not be the answer youre looking for, but just know that there tend to be fewer long-term problems associated with metal roofing than asphalt shingles or concrete tiles.
Here at Sheffield Metals, we think its important to educate consumers about the potential common problems with a metal roof that could very easily happen or not happen. In this article, well discuss:
- The top seven common problems that could occur with a metal roof
- Potential ways and methods to remedy or avoid the problem
- Important considerations to keep in mind to thatll help bypass some problems
Recommended Reading: How To Fix Roof Leak Around Chimney
Add Additional Attic Floor Pads
One of the most important things to do here is to ensure that you are not putting the insulation into corners where the attic floor and the roof walls wind up meeting. This is because it can create something of a cold area near the edge of the roof this can contribute to ice dam formation and it can block the air in-flow as well.
That additional attic floor padding will help to properly insulate your roof so as to keep it protected and to keep that additional heat from escaping into the roof itself. That additional insulation will go a long way towards preventing the buildup of ice and water, which leads to those pesky ice dams building up on your roof.
Cons Of Shingle Roofing
Shingle roofing is popular for the many reasons listed above, but there are some cons to consider.
Less Longevity than Metal
Shingles have a shorter lifecycle than their metal counterpart. Whereas metal roofing options can last 50-100 years, a shingle roof rarely lasts longer than 25 years. Here are the factors that cause shingle roofs to degrade vs. metal: before they hit 25 years, shingle roofs usually need at least some shingles replaced or repaired before a full-out roof replacement. Why? Because shingles damage easily, succumb to flaking, and are breeding grounds for algae, mold, and mildew.
Aesthetic Limitations
Shingle roofs can look neat and sophisticated, but they do not have the array of aesthetic options that metal roofing offers.
Its very difficult to dye a shingle or find one thats light in color. The asphalt limits the opportunity for vivid colors on shingle roofs. If you go the painting route, shingles will fade over time and get darker in the sun.
Heat Retention
Instead of refracting sun rays, shingle roofs absorb them because of the color and chemical makeup of the asphalt. This heat is usually transferred indoors, which can cause a spike in utilities if youre trying to maintain a cool environment. Additionally, asphalt is combustible, which can be detrimental in the case of house fires.
Non-Eco Friendly
Read Also: How To Fix A Loose Roof Shingle
Do Metal Roofs Require Less Maintenance
With a metal roof in a PVDF paint finish, you have a limited 30-year paint warranty. You will get a much longer aesthetic life of the panel compared to an asphalt shingle roof.
This is also another area where it seems clear that a metal roof costs less to maintain, but finding reliable supporting evidence is difficult.
As a metal roofing manufacturer if you ask me how you should maintain metal roofing panels, I will tell you to have a roofing service look at your roof every year to avoid long term problems. This is CYA legal talk.
The reality is that very few people do regular maintenance. Keep your roof free of debris and dont have dis-similar metals come into contact with the roof and you will be fine. This is especially true with standing seam metal roofing. If its installed properly, there is not a lot that can go wrong. Regular maintenance is designed to catch a minor problem early so that it does not become a major problem later.
If you have an exposed fastener panel, then you need to keep an eye on the screws to verify they were installed correctly, they have not backed out due to expansion and contraction, and that the washers have not worn out. If your budget permits, we recommend a standing seam panel so that you avoid all of these problems.
If you would like to learn more about metal roofing maintenance, read:
Is A Metal Roof Cheaper Than Shingles
Metal roofing is growing more and more popular in the roofing industry. This has sparked homeowners to start comparing the more commonly used asphalt shingle roof to metal roofing.
One of the biggest comparison questions we get is, Is a metal roof cheaper than shingles?
The team at Bill Ragan Roofing has over 30 years of experience answering questions just like this one. To ensure homeowners like you make the right purchasing decision, well be breaking down if a metal roof is cheaper than shingles.
Not only will we be comparing metal roof cost to shingle cost, but well also be comparing their lifespans, warranties, and more. By the end of this article, youll know which one is right for you and your replacement.
You May Like: Snow Guards For Corrugated Metal Roofs
You May Like: How To Clean Mold Off Roof Shingles
Roofing Diagnosis : Metal Roof Leaks Around Screws
When it comes to roofs, there are few products that can match the strength, durability, and performance that a metal roof can offer. But like just about anything else, metal roofs are not indestructible and they definitely can spring leaks.
Knowing where and how to identify leaks in a metal roof is the first step towards implementing the repairs that you will need to get your roof back into working order. Here are just a few things to look for if your metal roof is beginning to leak.
April 30, 2019 By Taylor-Made Roofing
How long do asphalt shingles last? Whether youre replacing your roof, inheriting an older roof, or simply exploring roofing materials, you might wonder about the lifespan of asphalt shingles. Tremendously common in American neighborhoods, asphalt shingles use bitumen to protect and waterproof roofs. Theyre prized for their beauty, durability, easy installation, and affordability. While asphalt shingles can last a long time, they wont survive forever.
Also Check: Can You Have Shingles All Over Your Body
Metal Roofs Are More Eco
In this day and age, making eco-friendly choices is the responsibility of every homeowner. Sustainability is another common ground for shingles vs In fact, many real estates also value the sustainability value of a house. Metal roofs are more eco-friendly as they are largely made of recycled material and can be recycled, again and again.
With their reflective surface, metal roofs help conserve more energy. You can also choose from a range of coatings that help optimize the effectiveness of air conditioners and reduce carbon footprints. A major backstep for asphalt shingle roofs is that they need to be replaced more frequently than metal roofs and cannot be recycled. Moreover, the heavy reliance on petroleum for their manufacturing makes them an inferior choice when it comes to the environment.
Also Check: Step By Step Metal Roof Installation
Recommended Reading: Does Red Roof Inn Allow Pets
So Which Is Better A Metal Roof Or Shingles
After you complete Steps 1 through 8, its time to make a decision. In most cases, an asphalt roof will be your choice if you have a smaller budget and find a style that you like. If you have a larger budget and live in an area with extreme weather, youll probably lean toward a metal roof.
If youre still not sure, do a bit more research. You may find that you actually prefer a slate or clay tile roof, for example. Getting a professionals opinion can also help you make a decision. Contact several local roofers to find out how much they charge to install a roof made of asphalt, metal or other materials.
The Pros And Cons Of Metal Roofs Vs Asphalt
There is no doubt that metal roofing is more contentious than asphalt roofing when it comes to home improvements. One side favors metal roofs because they offer better protection against the elements than asphalt, while the other favors it because it is less expensive and easier to maintain. Even though metal roofs may initially cost more, the cost difference over time may be insignificant. Furthermore, because metal roofs are less prone to wear and tear than asphalt shingles, they are less likely to fail.
Recommended Reading: Where To Buy Rubber Roofing Material
Metal Roofing Is Impervious To Fire Rot And Insect Damage
One of the principal reasons metal roofing has exploded in popularity is that it is virtually fireproof. With the dangers of wildfire on the rise, metal roofing has become the roofing material of choice in many parts of the country. And not only that:
- Insects such as termites can never eat metal roofing.
- Metal roofing is impervious to rot and mildew.
- Since it conducts heat quickly from the sun, snow slides off more quickly than with conventional roofing.
Metal Roofing Can Work On Roofs With Low Slopes
It’s often believed that metal roofing is suitable only for roofs with a steep slope, but standing-seam metal roofing can work fine on gently pitched roofs. This type of roofing is installed in large sheets with seams that are raised and sealed tightly together to resist water. While some slope is necessary to ensure water run-off, most homes can accept metal roofing.
You May Like: How To Install A Roof
How Much Does A Metal Roof Cost In Texas
The cost of a metal roof will vary widely based on many factors. It can be stated that a metal roof will normally cost more up-front than a basic shingle roof. But that initial cost difference can often be made up over the life of the roof due to it lasting longer and requiring less maintenance. As a baseline reference, asphalt shingles can cost between $100-$200 per square. Metal roofs can be done for as little as $120 to as much as $900 or more. Installation is also normally more expensive for a metal roof as it is a much more specialized skill.
Standing Seam Metal Roof Costs
Standing seam metal roofs have far superior longevity and last two or three times longer than non-metal roofs. They are the most common metal roof design due to its availability all over the U.S. to roofing installers and easy access to metal materials. The design features vertical panels that are joined by interlocking seams as seen below.
Read Also: Can You Overlap Metal Roofing Lengthwise
Don’t Miss: How Much Does Redoing A Roof Cost
Cons Of Metal Roofing
Metal roofing tends to come at a much higher price point than asphalt shingles. If installed incorrectly, their efficiency is not nearly as high, and they are difficult to install yourself. Metal roofing often requires an underlying plywood framing, which requires professional installation.
Some metal roofing is heavier to work with and can result in cuts to the skin when handled improperly or without the right set of gloves.
Dont Miss: How Much Do New Shingles Cost
Jan Why Is My Metal Roof Leaking 3 Likely Causes Of Premature Roof Leaks
There are countless reasons to have a commercial or residential metal roof installed. Theyre durable, environmentally sustainable, and dont typically require much maintenance. A painted metal roof can last for several decades and will even sustain 95% of its initial reflectance and emittance over time.
But even if a company uses the best residential or commercial metal roofing supplier for their metal roofing products, the high quality of the metal roof sheets wont make a difference if the installation isnt up to par.
In ideal circumstances, you shouldnt have to repair or replace metal roofs for quite some time. But the reality is that if a homeowner or business owner hires a contractor who doesnt specialize in steel roofing or if they choose to go the DIY route theres a lot that can go awry. And, unfortunately, the owner might not realize theres anything amiss until a rainstorm or a blizzard comes along, which can often result in emergency repair or replacement.
Remember: a brand new metal roof should not have leaks. If it does, its likely due to one of these three causes:
Don’t Miss: Is Red Roof Inn A Good Hotel
Metal Roofs Are More Energy
Industry studies show that metal roofs reflect solar radiant heat, which can reduce cooling costs by 10 to 25 percent. In climates where cooling costs are higher than heating costs, coating a metal roof with a shiny or granular coating can maximize the reflective capacity of the roof and improve energy savings.
Asphalt Roof Basics Pros And Cons
Asphalt shingles became the common way to roof a home at the start of the 20th century. Today, they’re considered the most popular material for roofing.
There are two forms of asphalt shingles: three-tab shingles and architectural shingles. Three-tab shingles lay flat and have three tabs or cutouts on each strip. Architectural shingles are laminated shingles. Compared to three-tab shingles, theyre thicker and provide more depth and dimension to your roof.
You May Like: What Causes Black Streaks On Roof Shingles
How Hot Does A Metal Roof Get In The Summer
A metal roof can get very hot in the summer, especially if it is dark-colored. If you are considering a metal roof for your home, you may want to choose a light-colored option to help keep your home cooler.
Heat absorbency will be affected by the color and finish of the metal. If you choose a pale color like white, you will absorb far less heat than if you chose a darker color like black. When the sun is at its most concentrated, it loses heat faster to the lightest materials on your roof, such as during the evening. The best color to select is lighter, which is more reflective in nature and is the most energy-efficient. It is very common for heat to transfer to the building beneath when these materials are extremely hot. Metal roofs will help to cool an attic below your roof, and it is now more important than ever to keep the temperature in that area cool.
Metal Roof Vs Shingle Roofing
Metal and asphalt shingles are two common roofing materials in the United States. If you need a new roof, consider whether you want a metal roof replacement or a shingle roof replacement. You can use this complete guide to metal roofs vs. asphalt shingles to help you decide which one is better for your budget and design preferences.
Don’t Miss: Are Steel Roofs Cheaper Than Shingles
Disadvantages Of A Metal Roof
Metal roofs can last a really long time, but they do have some disadvantages.
âCost: Metal roofs may be worth the cost because of how long they last, but they do cost a lot more than asphalt roofs.
âNoise: Noise can be a problem with some metal roofs. Using more insulation can decrease the noise, but this will add to the cost.
âDents: Some metal roofs can be prone to dents, which could mean more frequent repairs.
