What Do You Want From Your Roof
In summary, both metal roofing and asphalt shingles are popular and have their advantages.
For shingles, the advantages are price and low installation costs. While those are certainly valid considerations, both of those attributes are short-term. Conversely, metal roofing is well known for providing long-term value, exceptional performance, and a solid return on investment.
It all boils down to what you want. If low-cost today is your only criteria , then a shingle roof will be your best option. If, however, youre more interested in a roof that does the following, then metal roofing could be a serious consideration in your roof replacement journey:
- Lasts for decades
- Increases the curb appeal of your home
- Requires less maintenance
- Increases the value of your home
What Are Asphalt Shingles
The different types of asphalt shingles have improved greatly since their first debut in the United States back in the early 1900s. You can find many asphalt shingles types today available in different sizes, colors, and styles to suit different climates and home needs. They are perfect for many homeowners in need of new roofs.
Typically, asphalt shingle types are made of a material mixture including asphalt, granules, sealants, fiberglass, and release film. Stable resin is used to bind glass fibers to reinforce and add durability to the asphalt shingles, while the asphalt allows it to be water-resistant. The granules added to asphalt shingles provide color variety and UV protection. Typically, asphalt shingles are composed of layers: a base mat, layer of waterproofing asphalt, and a layer of ceramic granules.
While there are many types of asphalt shingles, they also come in fiberglass or organic makeup.
How Does This Affect Homeowners
If you believe your roof might need replacing, contact your roofer now. Prices have already risen and may not come back to their pre-COVID levels even after roofing supplies catch up with demand.
The first round of price increases will take effect January 1st and most manufactures have already announced that they will raise prices again on February 1st by another 4 to 7 percent.
Your cost for shingles is based on when theyre delivered not on when you ordered them. So the longer you wait, the more likely youll run into the next price increase.
The shortages also affect installation timelines. You may have to wait longer than normal to get your roof materials delivered for your project.
In some cases, it can take 6 to 8 weeks for manufactures to fulfill orders. Your roofer can help you navigate those delays, but they dont have any control over when prices will change.
Manufacturers are spending the majority of their production time on colors that are more common like weathered-woods and black shingles.
Lower volume colors and special order colors are going to be harder to get until manufacturers can recover from the current roofing material shortages.
Tip: Colors may be easier to get than brands in certain markets. In other words, if color is more important to you than a particular brand of shingles, ask your roofer to show you what colors other comparable brands may have available.
Read Also: Mobile Home Ceiling Panels Sagging
How Much Does A Metal Roof Cost Compared To Shingles
When faced with roof replacement, many homeowners have settled for the cheapest, most popular product – asphalt shingles. But over the past several years, a funny thing has happened. Homeowners, tired of the constant churn of shingle replacement, are searching for better roofing options.
Perhaps thats why residential metal roofing continues to gain in popularity. With increasing frequency, homeowners consider the possibilities of a metal roof on perhaps their most significant investment, their home. Based on recent data, metal roofing now holds 12% of the remodel market share and 8% of the spending for new residential construction.
Think about those statistics for a moment. That means 12% of the homes that need a roof replacement no longer replace their shingle roof with another shingle roof.
Because in many cases, theyre simply tired of the never-ending cycle of budgeting for and paying off a roof on their home. In the wise words of Albert Einstein, theyre just over the insanity of it all.
Consequently, large numbers of homeowners are researching the possibility of metal roofing for their home, and of course, product cost is a necessary component of any research effort. With metal roofing lasting three times as long, most homeowners expect the product to cost more however, the question is, how much more?
Shingle Roof Installation Cost
The total cost of installing a shingle roof consists of both material and labor costs. Labor is a significant factor and can comprise as much as 60% or more of the total project cost. So, for a job that ends up costing $12,000, at least $7,600 of that goes toward labor costs.
With labor, you may need to pay to tear off and dispose of the old shingles and underlayment. In some cases, it may be possible to leave the existing shingles in place and to install the new shingles on top.
Also Check: Proper Screw Placement Metal Roofing
Energy Efficient Rubber Roofs
Rubber roofing shingles consist of up to 95% recycled materials, including recycled rubber and a number of other recycled materials, such as plastic and slate dust. Additionally, used shingles can be melted and recycled into a new product. Rubber roofing is available in a number of different colors and styles, so you dont have to feel limited by the dark gray shade that is usually associated with rubber. In fact, if you live in a warm climate, investing in white-on-black rubber roofing can help increase energy efficiency as it is highly resistant to UV rays and absorbs heat.
Do You Need A New Roof
There’s no denying when a roof destroyed by fire, windstorm, hail, or other severe weather needs to be fixed. But often, the need for repair or replacement is signaled by a seemingly innocent ceiling stain or drip. That telltale sign can end up being fairly inexpensive to fix or may require a costly overhaul.
Sometimes you can find the leaks source yourself if you have an unfinished attic and can locate the water trickle along a rafter or stud. However, its best to have an experienced roofer do an inspection and handle the repairs. We dont recommend homeowners navigate steep ladders and pitched roofs themselves.
The remedy may be as simple as filling in a crack with caulk, replacing a few shingles, or installing some flashinga membrane of metal that redirects water. Most leaks can be stopped if theyre limited to a few spots. But if youre experiencing recurring leaks and your roof is out of warranty, a new roof is in order. Even without obvious signs of damage, its wise to replace an out-of-warranty roof thats more than 20 years old.
Don’t Miss: Briarwood Pro Shingles
Top Benefits Of Metal Roofing Compared To Shingles
- Metal roofing is durable and routinely lasts 2-4 times longer than shingles.
- Homeowners like the idea of buying only one more roof in their life instead of potentially several.
- Metal roofing outperforms shingles in cases of hail and other severe weather events.
- Metal roofing is highly reflective and can save 20-40% on electricity bills.
- Metal roofing has a high recycled content which means it helps reduce landfill pressure instead of adding to it like asphalt shingles.
- Metal roofing looks great, improving curb appeal and resale values.
Given the sharp increase in market share, it seems that more and more homeowners are making performance, not price, their dominant purchase decision.
Learn more about metal roof cost.
Whats The Difference Between Architectural Shingles And 3 Tab Shingles
Architectural shingles are thicker asphalt shingle types that can create the appearance of visually stunning natural roofing like slate, cedar, or clay tiles at a fraction of the cost. Because of their extra thickness and contouring, they cost more than traditional asphalt shingles, but they last longer from 30 to 50 years and carry longer warranties. They are fire resistant, wind resistant, and prevent algae and mold growth making them one of the most popular type of roof shingles.
Talk to Contractors
Also Check: Skylight On Metal Roof
Other Cost Factors To Consider
- Other factors that could raise the cost of roofing replacement projects include: thicker roofing material, high-quality underlayment or insulation, repairs, or an extended warranty agreement.
- The installation of rubber roofing is easier and quicker than other materials. The rubber is also lighter in weight, which makes it easier to deliver to your home.
- Rubber roofing will most likely cost more than asphalt roofing, but less than metal, slate, clay, and other premium types. Before you go with asphalt due to the low price, remember that the quality and performance is one of the highest for the price.
- Rubber roofing has to be properly installed in order to offer all of the typical benefits. Keep this in mind if you are considering handling the project yourself. Though the investment may be less daunting with DIY work, you may ultimately waste money on repairs or on home damage. Protect the investment of your new roof and this project by hiring someone who knows the ins and outs of rubber roofing installation.
- We suggest speaking to a local roof installer to see if a rubber roof is the best roof type to install for your home.
Find Local Pros
The Risks Of Trying To Get The Cheapest Roof Replacement Possible
Now you know what to consider when deciding which asphalt shingle is right for you. Even though the price of your new roof is always the biggest concern, you should always consider what you get out of your investment with the look, lifespan, and warranties that protect it.
While its alright to look for the most affordable roofing material, its crucial not to look for the cheapest roof replacement possible. This leads to stress, cutting corners during installation, and taking more money out of your pocket.
A cheap roof replacement might be tempting, but there are huge risks involved. Because we want every homeowner to avoid the problems that come with a cheap roof, were going to give you the 4 risks of getting the cheapest roof replacement possible.
The team at Bill Ragan Roofing has proudly helped homeowners in the Nashville area get a high-quality roof that fits their budget. We take the time to help you understand what goes into the cost of your new roof and why its important. And if you end up working with us, were proud to provide you with a lifetime warranty, so we can be there for you if theres ever a problem.
Don’t Miss: How To Get Roofing Leads Without Door Knocking
The Look Each Asphalt Shingle Gives Your Roof
When meeting with your local roofing contractor, youll have to choose the color and look you want your roof to have. Thats why you need to determine how important the look of your new asphalt roof is to you.
If you dont care about the look of your new roof, 3-tab shingles may be right for you. While 3-tab shingles still make good-looking roofs, dimensional and luxury shingles mimic other roof types to give you a distinct look.
If you want the cedar shake roof look without paying the cedar shake price, a dimensional asphalt shingle is the one for you. Luxury shingles give you a beautiful slate look, but it comes at a premium price.
All 3 types of asphalt shingles make good-looking roofs. But if you want your roof to really stand out, consider going with dimensional or luxury asphalt shingles.
Slate Tile Roofing Shingles
Slate roofing shingles are a stone roofing material that is installed as a shingle. Slate shingles are thin but very heavy when the whole roof is made out of them. Slate has a natural beauty to it that many people appreciate, but the shingles do not really vary in color or looks. Slate roofing shingles cost on average $8 to $14 per square foot or $800 to $1,400 per square to install. Slate tiles are more difficult to install but when done properly they will give you one of the longest-lasting roof options available. Slate shingles come with an expensive price tag, but that does not mean that slate is not a great roof type option if you can afford it. Many people decide slate roofs are worth the cost to install since they will last more than a lifetime from 60 to 150 years.
Recommended Reading: Exposed Fastener Metal Roof Screw Pattern
More Things To Consider When Deciding Which Asphalt Shingle Is Right For You
Now you know that asphalt is the cheapest roofing material for your roof replacement. You also just learned which asphalt shingle is right for someone on a tight budget.
While cost is the main thing every homeowner thinks about, there are a few more things to consider when deciding which asphalt shingle is right for your roof replacement.
Metal Roof Vs Asphalt Shingles
Comparing metal vs. asphalt shingles requires understanding all the pros and cons of the two. Metal roofs often invoke images of corrugated sheet metal in greens, blues and greys. But you can also find metal shingles coated with granules that look and act just like asphalt. You ll also find an eclectic mix of copper, Victorian and ultra-modern styles. It s not just sheet metal anymore.
Don’t Miss: House Trusses Cost
How To Choose The Best Shingle Styles
To choose the best shingle for your home, youll want to compare the various materials, types and styles. Youll also want to consider:
- Budget: Your budget goes a long way to narrowing down the type and style. You can choose from expensive luxury to budget shingles.
- Climate: Different materials and styles fair better in different environments.
- Wind: If you live in an area of the country with high winds, like hurricane regions and some mountain states, youll want to consult a professional. They will help you determine if you need Class F or Class G wind-rated shingles.
- Temperatures: Metal and slate both do extremely well in areas with heavy snowfall and extremely cold temperatures. Fiberglass asphalt shingles do well across a wide range of temperatures.
Classic Metal Roofing Systems
Classic has very good metal shingles line. The biggest issue is that they work on regional dealership basis. This means there is one contractor per region, no competition, expensive material pricing, and dealers also charge a premium price for installation. In some regions, dealers use pushy sales tactics, talk trash about competitors, but in reality their installation is no better than from small roofing companies.
In my region, the Classic dealer actually hires former Interlock Roofing installers by luring them for a couple more bucks an hour. This means that the quality of installation is on par across big dealerships. The problem with both dealers is that you speak with a pushy salesman and have no idea who your installer will be.
In different areas, these dealers use either subcontractors or directly employ the installers. Bigger dealers have multiple crews, usually subcontractors, who work on volume and want to finish your job as soon as possible, thereby sacrificing quality.
The company has been in business since 1980, and has been installing its US manufactured metal roofs around the globe. Its products are made from 95% recycled materials. They offer a number of beautiful aluminum shingles. They are designed to withstand even the harshest coastal climate conditions.
If you like the look of cedar, there is Rustic Shingle, which boasts a realistic wood texture and is available in 12 beautiful colors.
Don’t Miss: Where Do You Put The Screws On A Metal Roof
Whats The Lifespan Of 3 Tab Shingles
Despite what roofing manufacturers like to tell homeowners, the service life of 3 tab shingles is HIGHLY variable, depending on the quality of insulation and other roofing materials used, quality of the installation and the local environmental conditions. These shingles may last as little as 8 years or as long as 20+ years. On average, you can expect a budget asphalt roof to last 10-14 years.
Keep in mind that the majority of asphalt shingles of the 3 tab variety are not rated to withstand wind speeds of over 60 mph. If you happen to install them on a roof located in an area with stronger winds, you run a very high risk of shingles being blown off and early roof replacement.
Another factor that greatly degrades the service life of low budget shingles is regular exposure to moisture, ice damming, and severe temperature fluctuations. They also dont perform as well under extreme heat and constant exposure to UV rays from the sun.
Did you know? architectural shingles tend to come with minimal warranties of 30 years? Thats for low-cost options. And they can last longer against winds more than twice as strong as those that blow 3-tab shingles off the roof.
Is It Ok To Put New Roof Shingles Over Old Ones
Many homeowners who are trying to save as much as possible on a re-roof, consider the idea of installing new shingles over the existing ones, since its faster and can save over $1,000 on tear off and removal fees alone. Often this advice is offered by roofers who are trying to get the job and are willing to lower the labor costs by foregoing tear off work.
However, while this may initially sound attractive, its USUALLY not a smart idea to install asphalt shingles over the old shingles. Here are some points to consider and ask your roofer:
Does your local building code allow for two layers of shingles? Some do, while others dont. You dont want to do any kind of install that will be in violation with local building codes.
Is the existing roof old/rotting/leaking/overall bad shape? In any of these cases installing new shingles will not take care of your existing roofing problems, and can actually make them worse.
Does your shingle warranty allow for two layers of installation? Many manufacturers will automatically void the roofing warranty, if their shingles were installed on top of an existing roof.
Compromised roof ROI: If you go to sell your home, and the inspection discovers that the new roof is installed over old shingles, this may lower the overall value of the property and scare away some buyers who may worry about potential roofing problems.
You May Like: How Often Should You Get Your Roof Replaced